Why Eyes Wrinkle First (and What to Do About it)

Crow’s feet are often the canary in the coalmine — the first signs of aging that typically precede other facial wrinkles and fine lines. Why is this? The delicate skin around our eyes (the periorbital area) is relatively thinner and more vulnerable to the damaging effects of unprotected sun exposure, fluid retention, smoking, allergies, lack of sleep, genetics and age.

“As we age, the tissues that support the under-eye area weaken and fat that normally sits around the eye can shift forward, creating a puffy appearance,” explains Mona Gohara, MD, a board-certified dermatologist in New Haven, Connecticut.

There is a silver lining, though. Because skin around the eyes is so thin, it absorbs eye creams more easily and quickly, which can help it stay hydrated, supple and younger-looking.

“Skin around the eyes contains less collagen and fewer oil glands than other parts of the face. As a result, signs of aging often appear earlier in this area. At the same time, some improvements may become noticeable more quickly with the use of topical products,” says Marisa Garshick, MD, a board-certified dermatologist in New York City.

According to the American Academy of Dermatology (AAD), the most effective anti-aging skin care plan starts with healthy skin care routines when you’re young that include moisturizing daily. Using a special cream for the periorbital skin area is not always necessary.

“People bothered by puffiness, dryness or early signs of aging may benefit from an eye cream, while those with little to no under-eye concerns may not need a separate product,” Gohara says.

The Benefits of Eye Creams

“Almost anyone can benefit from eye creams, especially as a preventative,” says Mary Lupo, MD, a board-certified dermatologist in New Orleans, Louisiana.

But can eye creams help reduce under-eye bags and puffiness? “It depends on the underlying cause,” Gohara says. “If puffiness is due to fluid retention, inflammation or mild swelling, then yes, ingredients in eye creams may help reduce that problem — somewhat. If under-eye bags or puffiness are due to prominent fat pads, significant skin laxity or genetics, eye creams have limited benefits.”

Some periorbital skin concerns may require in-office procedures or even surgery to correct. Lupo considers surgery “the gold standard” for removing big under-eye pads, for example.

Eye creams can help camouflage less prominent eye bags and puffiness — temporarily. “Think of eye creams as helping with the puffiness, but not changing the underlying anatomy,” Gohara says.

Key Ingredients

In a research review published in the International Journal of Women’s Dermatology, researchers matched common eye cream ingredients with the periorbital skin issue they potentially address. “Ingredients such as retinoids, vitamin C and caffeine show promise in addressing wrinkles and hyperpigmentation, while peptides and hyaluronic acid aid in collagen production and hydration. Niacinamide and ceramides offer benefits in reducing wrinkles and enhancing the skin barrier function,” the authors write.

Science is lacking, however, when it comes to determining which eye cream formulas work best. “The lack of clinical trials specifically targeting eye cream formulations and periorbital skin is a notable limitation,” researchers note.

Gohara agrees that current science is limited. “The strongest evidence exists for retinoids and caffeine, while peptides and antioxidants have growing but more modest supporting data,” she says.

Here’s more about which ingredients are shown to target common skin issues:

  • Dark circles: “Antioxidants like vitamin C can help brighten the area and protect against environmental damage,” Gohara says.
  • Under-eye bags and puffiness: “Caffeine is one of the best-studied ingredients for puffiness because it temporarily constricts blood vessels and can help reduce swelling,” Gohara says. Topical caffeine in concentrations up to 3% is considered safe and easily absorbed.
  • Crow’s feet, wrinkles and fine lines. “Retinoids can improve skin thickness and firmness over time by stimulating collagen production,” Gohara says. But because it can be irritating for some people, it’s best to stick to products with low concentrations.
  • Drooping eye lids: “Peptides may help support skin structure,” Gohara says. Other health researchers aren’t so sure because much of the data on peptides is early-stage and short-term. Learn the truth about peptides.
  • Dry, itchy, crepey skin: Topical eye creams containing ceramides are widely used for the treatment of dry skin. Hyaluronic acid moisturizes too. “Hydrating ingredients like hyaluronic acid can provide an immediate plumping effect that softens the appearance of fine lines,” Garshick says.

Be Gentle

When choosing an eye cream, “Look for gentle, fragrance-free formulas specifically for the eye area, especially if you have sensitive skin,” Garshick says. Eye serums tend to be lighter than creams and will penetrate the skin tissue more easily.

Lauren Fine, MD, a board-certified dermatologist in Chicago, suggests testing an eye cream first on another area of the skin before applying it to the face to gauge your skin’s reaction. “It’s one of the most common concerns and complaints I see among my patients,” she says. “Can eye creams help? One hundred percent.”

Related Posts