Are Lip Plumping Products Safe and Effective?
Q:Lip plumping products are popular, but are they safe? Are some products better than others? How do they work?
Lip plumping products work by temporarily increasing blood flow to the lips. Most of them cause a mild contact irritation due to ingredients such as cinnamon oil, menthol and capsaicin, which result in temporary (and sometimes uncomfortable) swelling. Lip plumpers that have hyaluronic acid in them work by drawing water into the skin.
Lip plumping products are considered safe, but their results won’t last and they may only produce mild to modest volume. Some people experience tingling, burning, hives and allergic contact reactions, so be careful when using them. If you experience discomfort, stop using the product immediately and see a board-certified dermatologist if problems persist.
Plumping lipsticks and lip balms are common sources of allergens that cause allergic rashes on the lips, especially in women. Typical offenders include fragrances, flavoring agents, propolis, lanolin, dyes and certain preservatives.
Lips are essentially an exposed portion of the lining of the inside of the mouth, so it’s important to treat them gently and keep them moisturized and protected from the sun. Transepidermal water loss is three times higher on the lips than on the cheeks, which means they are much more susceptible to dryness. What’s more, there are no oil glands or hair follicles on the lips, and they have minimal melanin compared with facial skin, which makes the lips more vulnerable to sun damage.
I recommend using fragrance-free lip products, layered with sun protection factor (SPF) for the lips. To protect them from dryness, I prefer plain petrolatum, which is highly occlusive and good at preventing water loss that can lead to cracking. Lip SPF is very important. Be sure to use a lip balm or lipstick that has SPF 30 or greater.